Direct write-off method vs allowance method — AccountingTools (2024)

FAQs

Direct write-off method vs allowance method — AccountingTools? ›

Direct Write-Off Method: Recognizes bad debts only when they become uncollectible, resulting in immediate but delayed expense recognition. Allowance Method: Estimates bad debts in advance, providing a more accurate and compliant approach to financial reporting by adhering to the matching principle.

Direct write off method advantages

Tax deductions: You can write off your bad debt on annual tax returns, according to the IRS. By contrast, the IRS won't accept bad debts written off using the allowance method, because it uses estimates rather than precise figures.

The direct write-off method recognizes bad accounts as an expense at the point when judged to be uncollectible and is the required method for federal income tax purposes. The allowance method provides in advance for uncollectible accounts think of as setting aside money in a reserve account.

For financial accounting purposes, the allowance method is preferred over the direct write-off method because it more accurately conveys financial information.

Answer and Explanation: The correct option is C) The expense is recognized when the account is written off rather than in the period of sale. In the direct write-off method, the bad debt expense is debited each time an individual customer account is identified as being uncollectible and written off.

Drawbacks of the direct write-off method

Because write-offs frequently occur in a different year than the original transaction, it violates the matching principle; one of 10 GAAP rules. The matching principle states that any transaction that affects one account needs to affect another account during that same period.

The allowance method can be better for a business than the direct write-off method because: The bad debts expense closer to the point of the sale or service. The allowance prepares a more accurate estimation of end-of-period financials, so the business knows what they have and how to prepare.

While both methods ultimately reduce accounts receivable and recognize a bad debt expense, the timing and approach are different. In practice, the allowance method is more commonly used because it adheres to the matching principle and is in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP).

The direct write-off method overstates assets on the balance sheet.

Allowance Method for Uncollectible Accounts

The direct write-off method works by directly writing-off bad debt expenses from accounts receivable into the expense account. Whenever a company is sure a certain account balance is uncollectible, it will debit bad debt expense and credit accounts receivable for the amount.

What is one disadvantage of the allowance method? ›

One disadvantage of the allowance method (over the direct write-off method) for recording uncollectible accounts is that it generally matches bad debt expense with the revenue it helped to generate.

The main advantage of using the allowance method in business is; it allows the firm to provide accurate financial reports to the interested parties. The accurate account receivable in the balance sheet can be estimated through allowance method.

Why is the allowance method preferred over the direct write-off method of accounting for bad debts? Allowance method is used for tax purposes. Estimates are used. Determining worthless accounts under direct write-off method is difficult to do.

Why is the allowance method preferable to the direct write-off method? The allowance method recognizes the expense of a bad debt in the same period as the sale.

The direct write-off method recognizes bad accounts as an expense at the point when judged to be uncollectible and is the required method for federal income tax purposes. The allowance method provides in advance for uncollectible accounts think of as setting aside money in a reserve account.

Timing Differences

Bad debt expense recognition is delayed under the direct write-off method, while the recognition is immediate under the allowance method. This results in higher initial profits under the direct write-off method.

The direct write-off method is the simplest method to book and record the loss on account of uncollectible receivables, but it is not according to the accounting principles. It also ensures that the loss booked is based on actual figures and not on appropriation. But it violates the accounting principles.

While both methods ultimately reduce accounts receivable and recognize a bad debt expense, the timing and approach are different. In practice, the allowance method is more commonly used because it adheres to the matching principle and is in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP).

The allowance method is an estimate of the amount the company expects will be uncollectible made by debiting bad debt expense and crediting allowance for uncollectible accounts. If a specific account becomes uncollectible, it will debit allowance for doubtful accounts and credit accounts receivable.