Homeowners Insurance: Are You Over- or Underinsured? (2024)

Trying to get just the right amount of homeowners insurance for your house and possessions may leave you feeling a bit like Goldilocks searching for a chair, a bed, and porridge that are just right. If you underinsure your home and suffer a devastating loss — flood, fire, theft — you risk not being able to return to the lifestyle you've worked hard to achieve. Yet if you overinsure, you're throwing money away every year on unnecessarily high premiums.

What you need is coverage that's just right. Here's how to get it, and it shouldn't take more than four or five hours of your time spent reviewing yourhomeownersinsurance policy, talking to your agent, and doing a little research.

Look Before You Leap Into a Policy

All homeowners insurance isn't created equal. That's why it pays toreview your coverageevery year to ensure your policy meets your evolving needs. Begin by understanding the types of coverage available.

Actual cash value coverage reimburses you for the value of your home based on its current condition, explains Marjorie Young, senior vice president at E.G. Bowman Co., a New York City insurance brokerage. If your home was built 10 years ago, you'd receive only the depreciated value of decade-old windows, cabinets, appliances, and so on.

Most insurers recommend the more comprehensive replacement cost coverage. With it, says Young, you'll be reimbursed for the amount it will cost to rebuild your home like new with the same kind and quality of materials. Depreciation doesn't factor into the settlement equation.

To get the full benefit of replacement coverage, you need to purchaseenough insuranceto cover the total cost to rebuild your home, excluding the value of the land. Many people make the mistake of insuring at the market value. But the amount you could sell your home for today isn't necessarily the same as how much it would cost to rebuild.

Construction Costs Play Big Role

Looktocurrent construction costs in your local area for guidance. If you've purchased a newly constructed home in the past year, you already have the answer. The same is true if you've refinanced within the past year. You almost certainly paid for an appraisal during that process that likely includes three valuations: replacement cost, market value, and actual cash value.

If you're determining replacement cost without those head-starts, call several local homebuilders and asking the average square-foot construction cost in your area. If the going rate is $175 and your home is 2,000 square feet, you'd purchase $350,000 in coverage.

Remember that any time you spend at least 5% of your home's value on a remodeling project — or $5,000, whichever is less — you should contact your insurer to increase your coverage. Young recently did that after she revamped her own kitchen. An additional $40,000 in homeowners coverage raised her annual premium by about $40.

Don't Neglect Valuables, Liability

Be sure you're also insured at the right value for your home's contents and for personal liability. Most insurance polices provide only actual cash value on contents, says Lisa Lobo, vice president of underwriting operations at The Hartford in Southington, Conn. To get replacement cost coverage, you'll need to purchase an endorsem*nt. If you have valuables not covered by your policy — silverware, jewelry, furs— purchase endorsem*nts for those, too.

Many people pay no attention to the liability coverage limits in their policies, but that's a mistake. If you have a dinner party and a guest falls down your front steps, you don't want to be underinsured. In recent years theaverage liability claimfor bodily injury and property damage has been $15,854.

If you're concerned about increasing your premiums by adding endorsem*nt after endorsem*nt, ask whether you can save money by splitting your deductible, paying a higher amount for certain claims and a lower amount for others. Bundled endorsem*nts can save you a few bucks, but only if you require them all. Take a pass on unneeded riders. Why spend $8 to $12 a year for $500 worth of refrigeratedproperty coveragewhen you eat takeout every night?

Related:

Homeowners Insurance: Are You Over- or Underinsured? (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to be over-insured or underinsured? ›

While being overinsured is preferable to being underinsured, doing so may hinder your financial goals. If you're overinsured, here are some ways to reduce your coverage and save on costs. Review your policy regularly. Review your policies periodically or when your situation changes and adjust where needed.

What should you not say to homeowners insurance? ›

Don't Admit Fault

Misstatements could lead to a claim being denied and even allegations of insurance fraud. However, that doesn't mean taking the blame for damage you didn't cause after a disaster has struck your property.

What is the 80% rule in homeowners insurance? ›

When it comes to insuring your home, the 80% rule is an important guideline to keep in mind. This rule suggests you should insure your home for at least 80% of its total replacement cost to avoid penalties for being underinsured.

How do I make sure I am not underinsured? ›

How to Avoid Underinsuring Your Home
  1. Don't Skimp on Homeowners Insurance. ...
  2. Consider Construction Cost Increases. ...
  3. Insure Your Home Based on Replacement Cost. ...
  4. Consider Building Code Upgrade Coverage. ...
  5. Check Your Sub-Limits. ...
  6. Update Your Policy if You Do Home Renovations.

What are the disadvantages of being underinsured? ›

The Risks of Being Underinsured
  • The Costs of Emergency Home Repairs Can Add Up. ...
  • You May Not Be Adequately Covered For Flood Damage. ...
  • Your High-Value Items Might Not Be Sufficiently Covered. ...
  • Your Policy May Be Cancelled. ...
  • You May End Up With a High Deductible After An Accident. ...
  • Filing Claims Can Become a Nightmare.
Feb 26, 2019

What is an example of underinsured? ›

Car insurance

You cause an accident and are deemed liable for the other driver's medical expenses of $50,000. Since you only carry $25,000 of bodily injury, you are technically $25,000 underinsured for this claim, which you would be responsible for paying out of pocket.

How to scare a home insurance adjuster? ›

Insurance adjusters often start with a lowball offer, hoping you will accept it without question. To scare an insurance adjuster, you must demonstrate that you know the true value of your claim. Reject the lowball offer in writing and provide a detailed explanation of why you believe the offer is inadequate.

Should you insure your home to its full value? ›

Replacement cost is how much it would cost to reconstruct your home as it is now, and most homeowners policies offer replacement cost coverage. However, if you don't insure to the full value of your home, you may find yourself responsible for a significant portion of the rebuilding costs in the event of a loss.

What is the rule of thumb for homeowners insurance? ›

Your dwelling coverage should equal the replacement cost of your house, which is the amount of money it would take to build a replica of your home. At the bare minimum, you should definitely have replacement cost coverage (or RCV) for your home, which is what pretty much all standard policies offer anyway.

How many quotes should you get for homeowners insurance? ›

Homeowners insurance covers your home, personal belongings, and liability claims. You can get quotes online or by working directly with a home insurance agent. Plan on getting at least three quotes to make sure you find the best policy for your budget.

How to know if you're underinsured? ›

You may need to revisit the amount (and type) of life insurance coverage you have if:
  1. Your family has grown.
  2. Your stay-at-home spouse is not insured.
  3. You only have group life insurance through work.
  4. Your income rose.
  5. You have significant debt.
  6. Your financial goals have changed.
Dec 19, 2023

How to avoid underinsurance? ›

Ways to avoid being underinsured
  1. Check the amount you are insured for. ...
  2. Add up the value of your contents room by room. ...
  3. Work out the cost to replace the item now, not what you paid for it. ...
  4. Include any new high value items or heirlooms you have. ...
  5. Think about items you want to cover when you're out and about.

Who is most likely to be underinsured? ›

Two groups of adults are of particular concern, young adults (ages 18 through 24 years) because of their high uninsured rate (29 percent) and midlife adults (ages 55 through 64 years) whose uninsured rate is lower than average (14 percent) but whose family incomes have begun to decline, on average, and who have a ...

What happens if you are over insured? ›

Over-insurance happens when your property is insured for more than its actual value. This means you're essentially covered too much, leading to unnecessarily high premium payments that don't match the worth of your property. It's a common misstep that can significantly strain your finances without any real benefit.

Why do you need underinsured motorist coverage? ›

"Underinsured motorist" coverage ("UIM") provides the same type of protection in cases where a negligent person does not have enough of their own auto insurance coverage to pay for all of the damages sustained by the insured person who owns the UIM coverage.

What is the effect of being underinsured? ›

In cases where the insurance sum is too low, companies are at risk of not being able to secure the necessary compensation to recover from a fire or flood or other property damages. Therefore, the outcome of being underinsured can, in the worst-case situation, stop the company from completely re-establishing operations.

What are the risks of over insurance? ›

If an insured over-insures a property and a loss occurs, the individual may end up profiting from the loss, potentially creating a motivation to cause a loss to realize a profit; this scenario perpetuates damage to the insurance industry in the form of fraud.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Last Updated:

Views: 5579

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dr. Pierre Goyette

Birthday: 1998-01-29

Address: Apt. 611 3357 Yong Plain, West Audra, IL 70053

Phone: +5819954278378

Job: Construction Director

Hobby: Embroidery, Creative writing, Shopping, Driving, Stand-up comedy, Coffee roasting, Scrapbooking

Introduction: My name is Dr. Pierre Goyette, I am a enchanting, powerful, jolly, rich, graceful, colorful, zany person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.